Front Office Notes from Mindset Curated - June 2026
June has a particular energy in independent schools. The school year is over. The awards are given. The seniors are gone. And for a few weeks, there is space to think.
This issue is about what is happening in the broader landscape of school sports right now. A coaching shortage that is getting structurally worse. A participation crisis that Congress is treating as a public health emergency. NIL creeping toward high school. A quiet decline in boys’ sports that most schools are not tracking. And a vote on college eligibility rule change coming in a few weeks.
These trends are already showing up inside your programs, whether you can see them or not. Use the space well.
— Mike
On the Radar
Six trends shaping school athletics right now
1. The Coaching Shortage Just Got Measurably Worse
The 2026 Coach & AD annual survey surfaced something most ADs already feel: “finding quality assistants” jumped from the 10th most pressing concern to No. 1 in a single year. The applicant pool is thinning. One Massachusetts AD described it as having gone from “the Pacific Ocean to the kiddie pool.”
What makes this harder is what coaches actually want: professional development in team culture (70%), leadership (51%), and sports psychology (40%). Sport-specific training barely registers. Coaches know what the job requires. The question is whether their schools are building the infrastructure to support them in doing it.
The shortage is real. It is being made worse by how most schools onboard, develop, and retain the coaches they already have.
Source: Coach & Athletic Director 2026 Coaches Survey / Boston Globe, May 2025
2. Congress Called It a Public Health Crisis
In December 2025, Congress held a formal hearing titled “Benched: The Crisis in American Youth Sports and Its Cost to Our Future.” The headline finding: 70% of youth athletes quit organized sports by age 13.
Two parallel crises emerged from the testimony. In lower-income communities, kids have almost no access to sports. In middle and upper-income communities, children are burned out by early specialization before they reach high school.
Independent schools are not insulated from the second one. The burnout cycle Congress identified might be happening inside your programs too.
Source: House Committee on Education & the Workforce, December 2025
3. NIL Is Coming to High School. Ready or Not.
Forty states now permit some form of high school NIL. Stanford economist Roger Noll put it plainly in Education Next: “There’s a whole other world ten times as big as college athletics that’s about to face serious issues. There’s a three- or four-year lag, but it’s coming.”
Talent is already migrating toward schools with better resources and brand-able programs. Agents are approaching families of 15-year-olds. The risk for independent schools is not that your athletes become NIL stars. It is that NIL accelerates a consolidation dynamic already in motion, and schools without a clear philosophical position on what athletics is for will get pulled along without ever making a conscious choice.
Source: Education Next, Spring 2025
4. Boys Are Quietly Dropping Out
The gender gap in youth sports is narrowing. That sounds like good news. It is not.
Boys’ participation has dropped 9 percentage points over the past decade, according to the American Institute for Boys and Men. Girls’ participation has held steady. The gap is closing because fewer boys are playing. Among low-income boys, only 25% participate at all. Sports are the only extracurricular activity where boys participate more than girls. When they lose that anchor, they often lose meaningful school engagement with it.
The contributing factors include rising costs, fewer male coaches as role models, and eligibility policies that disproportionately cut the boys who need the connection most. Worth examining inside your own program.
Source: American Institute for Boys and Men, March 2025
5. The Participation Data Is More Complex Than the Headlines
The Aspen Institute’s State of Play 2025 report shows 55% of youth played organized sports in 2023, up slightly from 2022. Casual participation surged 6% in 2024, the highest level on record.
But the income gap is growing: a 20-point participation gap between high- and low-income families, the largest ever tracked. Flag football was the only team sport to grow regular participation from 2019 to 2024. Boys volleyball grew 13% in 2024 to 2025, the fastest-growing boys sport in the country.
The better question for independent school ADs is not what the national data shows. It is what your own participation data shows about who your program is actually serving.
Source: Aspen Institute Project Play, State of Play 2025
6. The NCAA’s 5-in-5 Rule Is One to Watch
The NCAA Division I Cabinet is expected to vote in late June on a new age-based eligibility model. Under the updated “5-in-5” proposal, athletes receive five years of eligibility. The clock starts upon initial full-time enrollment in college or at the beginning of the academic year following their 19th birthday, whichever occurs first. The cabinet removed earlier language that tied the clock to high school graduation.
The vote is imminent and the implications for independent schools, particularly those with post-graduate programs, are still coming into focus. This is one to watch closely before drawing conclusions.
Source: ESPN / On3, June 2026 | NCAA Division I Cabinet, May 2026
Front Office Notes is published quarterly by Mindset Curated Advisory Services. Mike Marich partners with independent schools to build mission-aligned athletic programs through leadership development, organizational strategy, and culture design.
1 Like